Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pies

Today, we are committed to recreating that very key lime pie I once made for my family and my friends, and making it with the freshest ingredients we can. We're not cutting corners, we're not looking at changing the basic five-ingredient recipe, and we're certainly not looking to minimize costs at the expense of the authenticity and integrity of the product. A number of years ago, while my daughter and I were vacationing in the Keys, I visited what was (and might still be) the most popular key lime pie shop in Key West. The proprietor of the bakery and I were chatting (shop-talk) about business, since we are all somewhat aware of one another. I was amazed when I mentioned the raising cost of butter (thinking he would concur), and he asked why are you buying butter?

Made in Brooklyn

Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pies
204 Van Dyke St
Brooklyn, NY 11231

Get in Touch!

inquiry@keylime.com